It’s been over a month since Oakland Tech implemented Yondr pouches. The policy had a rocky start, with students entering and exiting campus chaotically and creating lines after the bell. Unfamiliarity with the process generated widespread confusion among both students and staff. Students have also expressed different perspectives on the new phone ban, with reactions ranging from strong support to remaining critical. Oakland Tech teachers and staff have provided many positive perspectives on the new phone policy.
”There is definitely an increase in team building,” Computer Science capstone teacher Ms. Ketcham expressed, “it felt like I traveled through time for how much students are talking to each other rather than being on their phones.”
Students, however, have expressed a more negative view of Yondr and the state phone ban.
“I think it’s stupid,” said Senior Ezra Spivak, “I think it’s better just to use the phone box because kids can still use their phones.”
Some teachers don’t enforce the policy as required. Instead of taking the phones and then handing them to the administration, they simply tell students to put them away, even after multiple warnings.
Within the first month, students have struggled to get onto campus, meet up with friends, get transportation, and pay for food. Students who have found the pouches ineffective have adapted, often by sneaking them in or replacing real phones with decoys.
“There is always a workaround,” states sophomore Jack Peck.
Students suggest that phone boxes were a better method, as teachers would watch students put phones away before class, and students could get them back by the end of class. Alternative approaches to Oakland Tech’s phone ban are also gaining traction, such as allowing device use during lunch breaks or restricting phones only during instructional time rather than a bell-to-bell ban.
California Governor Gavin Newsom passed Assembly Bill 3216, also known as the Phone-Free School Act, into law on September 23, 2024, mandating that every school district, charter school, and county office of education in California be required to adopt and implement a local policy limiting or prohibiting student smartphone use during school hours. Every district was required to put these policies in place by July 1, 2026. The Phone-Free School Act’s main goal was to increase academic focus, protect mental health, combat cyberbullying, and encourage socialization between students. The state law mandates that a policy exist, but it leaves the specific enforcement method up to individual school districts.
Districts such as San Jose, Dublin, and San Diego Unified vary in strictness, and many other Bay Area districts have not implemented the same restrictions on technology. The San Jose School District complied by having students turn off their devices and put them in their backpacks. Dublin has students put devices in cellphone pockets. While Oakland is pursuing a unique approach compared to other districts, it remains unclear whether its $500,000 investment has yielded measurable results.
Out of the 100+ districts that cover the Bay Area, OUSD is one of the few that have implemented Yondr pouches. At the June 24, 2026, OUSD School Board meeting, Nelson Alegria, OUSD’s executive director of safety, presented multiple surveys showing “more than two-thirds of 38 school administrators support the full cellphone ban,” according to Oakland North. However, the survey did not include the input of the approximately 34,000 students in OUSD.
On the other hand, this investment brings up concerns about emergencies. Following last year’s shooting at Skyline High School, campus safety has become an even greater priority across the district. Senior Blake Rodgers says, “It’s scary to think about not having access to my phone if something like that happens again.”
Despite the friction surrounding the rollout, some faculty members feel the policy has transformed their day-to-day teaching.
“Oh, so much better,” says Freshman English and Ethnic Studies teacher Ms. Kuan, “honestly incomparable to previous years…It’s been one of the best years so far.”