This summer, PBS published a poll claiming that 65% of U.S. residents were “proud to be an American.” This fall, the Scribe visited 12 classrooms to conduct anonymous polling. Out of 204 students, 30% shared this sentiment.
This question has two parts. Students must first consider what it means to be an American. For many, this means more than simply living in the country. While some feel it means being part of the nation’s culture, others feel the privilege of freedom is a central identifier.
“I think [being American] means to be free, you know, have freedoms, you can do what you want to do,” asserts Eric Truong, a senior at Tech.
Despite nearly every Tech student being part of this previously defined America, less than 30% find pride in it. The cause may be phrasing. “American pride” has a strong connotation, especially in a community commonly ranked as one of the country’s most liberal. Multiple students who voted yes did not want to comment on their reasoning when told these opinions would go public in the Scribe. Conversely, almost every student voting no was willing to have their reasons heard.
Agustín Arroyo Bustamante, a student who voted no, justified his answer with the government’s biases and wealth favoritism.
“ It gets to a point where I do have a voice, but I feel like, to make a difference, it’s most likely never gonna happen. There’s, like, money required to make a difference. I feel like [there is] a class requirement.”
Augustin’s perspective is based on real issues. Currently, the top 1% of Americans hold roughly 31.7% of the country’s total wealth, more than the bottom 90% of Americans combined. This top 1% can express their will through means such as lobbying—the deliberate attempt by individuals, groups, or organizations to influence the government and its policies.
It is important to understand that not everyone who voted yes is proud of these problems. Many of these students voted so for other, broader reasons, like the country’s privileges and the government’s unique federal strengths and limits, such as free speech. The ability to critique—as voiced in this article and through student polling—is, to many, something to be proud of.
“…The fact that I don’t like some of the stuff that [the Trump administration is] doing, the fact that a lot of people don’t like the stuff that they’re doing, is kind of proof that the system’s working,” claims Tenzin Pahl, an Oakland Tech senior who voted yes.
Our ability to dislike this administration is more important now than ever. It is evident students have opinions; 204 of us had the opportunity to express one in a poll. Our ability to voice our thoughts and grievances is a privilege—one we cannot let go. If you have the strength to tally a yes or no, don’t leave it there. Send your grievances to your representatives, post them on social media, sign up for voter eligibility—take matters into your own hands.